The Dangerous Trap of Chasing Subscriber Numbers


Hi Reader

I deleted thousands of readers from my email list a few days ago.

If you’re reading this, you escaped the cut!

Here’s why:

When I started my email list, my mission was to get 1,000 subscribers.

I asked friends and family to join my list and gave away a PDF on my website.

I hit my goal after a few months.

Then, I set a new goal of reaching 10,000 subscribers.

I used every strategy I could think of to hit it:

Facebook ads, content upgrades, outreach campaigns, competitions, and multiple lead magnets.

One lead magnet over-performed.

I explained how to turn a fancy Moleskine notebook into a system for Getting Things Done (a popular productivity technique).

I took pictures for my guide and wrote a lengthy tutorial.

The magnet attracted hundreds of subscribers.

But they weren’t interested in any of my offers or courses.

They wanted the guide only.

So, I had to remove them manually from my list.

Dozens of hours, a few hundred dollars, wasted.

I want to tell you I only made this mistake once.

But I also created content upgrades for blog posts.

They covered how to get more done in OS X and Excel… things that had NOTHING to do with my core business.

Again, I felt good about my rapidly growing subscriber count but less good when they read my emails and were like WTF?!

The bill from my email marketing provider was another painful reminder that I needed a strategy, not just another growth tactic.

So, I only create lead magnets that align with my core offer these days.

I also regularly remove people who are not a good fit for what I write about or sell.

My list isn’t for people interested in free PDFs, generic productivity tips, or a low-paying content writing gig.

I create for serious writers, coaches, and content creators looking to grow their businesses.

Growing a list isn’t just about hitting an arbitrary or round number on the backend of ConvertKit or Substack.

It’s more like a dinner party where only the right guests get your invite.

Write on,
Bryan Collins

$97.00

Write Profitable Emails

On this LIVE 90-minute workshop, I'll show you my process for writing profitable daily emails.
It takes place on... Read more

Letters From the Desk of Bryan Collins

Do you want to grow a profitable content business? If so, join 25,000 readers. I share daily insights about personal brand building, writing online and growing a profitable business. It's for creators, coaches and business owners.

Read more from Letters From the Desk of Bryan Collins

Hi Reader Over a million of young Italians left their country in the past 10 years. These 25–34-year-olds are saying arrivederci to cities like Rome, Florence and Milan because of low salaries and job opportunities. A few years ago, Ireland faced the exact same problem. Thousands of Irish my age quit the country and boarded planes to countries like Australia and the US because the Irish government bailed out the banks. A good chunk of these emigrating Irish never came home. A few friends of...

Hi Reader, Forget the algo. Don't worry about going viral. The real action lies in building an email list or newsletter. Many paths to monetization exist for newsletter owners. Here's one: Build an email list, and you'll get invites to 3rd party bundles and promotions. I say no to most 3rd part promotions. They're either not a good fit or I don't believe they'll convert. But, I regularly partner up with InfoStack. If you haven't heard of them, they bundle courses and products from across the...

Hi Reader Google is facing BIG problems in 2025. And I don’t just mean the US Justice Department telling the boffins at Mountain View to sell off Chrome. Search is one of Google’s core products, and frankly, it’s broken. As a search user, finding what I want is harder because the results are often wrong, unhelpful, or take ages to wade through. As a content publisher and creator, ranking a site in search is harder because the algo favors Reddit and giga-chad brands like our ex-friends at...