The Hidden Downside of Giving Away Too Much Value


Hi Reader,

Want to fix a toilet, cook a roast dinner, or start a blog?

Google “How to…”

Or YouTube it.

The net gives away a lot of stuff we take for granted.

When building my writing website, I invested hours and dollars in producing explainers, tutorials, guides, and how-to articles.

Topics people type into Google or YouTube when they’re stuck.

A lot of this content crushed it (traffic-wise).

Some examples of high-traffic value posts?

How to Use Scrivener for Blogging

The Ultimate Guide to Writing a Book

A Guide to Finding the Perfect Book Cover Designer

This type of valuable content attracts traffic, readers, and viewers in droves.

People love how-to content. They’ll bookmark, consume, read, and save it. They’ll even write in.

Giving away value content worked out ok for me for a few years. All that juicy traffic translated into ad revenue from AdSense and YouTube.

But I discovered a painful lesson about giving away so much freeking value.

Create how-to-value content to grow an audience and go viral. But consumers of freely available value content rarely buy.

Sure, they’ll follow your guides and tutorials but once they get what they want, they don’t need you anymore. Adios!

What’s more…

Some will even write in to complain or leave nasty comments because they couldn’t follow a step.

The other day, a dude left a comment on a tutorial video I recorded—one thousands of other viewers successfully followed—to say, “Didn’t work.”

Creating value content is kind of like putting on a buffet. Anyone and everyone will turn up. They’ll pick and choose, and some will leave a mess.

So what should you do instead?

If you want to sell products and earn more money, create content based on your insights.

It’s more like fine dining. You won’t attract the masses; instead, it’ll appeal to a high-end audience.

Explain what you did and what you learned. Describe your philosophy about the problem or topic.

Then, save the best stuff for your paid products.

You won’t get as much traffic or views, but this type of content converts more leads into clients.

It’s more fun to create, and you’ll earn more, too.

If you need help fixing your content strategy so you can add $10k to your business, reply “INSIGHT” to this email.

Write on,
Bryan Collins

Grammarly is running a back-to-school offer for September. You can claim 50% off any Grammarly plan.

I've partnered with Grammarly as it's a tool I use for my business. I use this app daily for grammar checking, plagiarism checkers, AI generation, and more.

Claim your 50% discount

Bryan Collins's newsletter

Do you want to grow a profitable content business? If so, join 25,000 readers. I share daily insights about personal brand building, writing online and growing a profitable business. It's for creators, coaches and business owners.

Read more from Bryan Collins's newsletter
A man laying in a hammock on a patio

Hi Reader, I stopped doing a few things this year. I bought into the myth of hustle culture. So, I started over-engineering my business. An example? I segmented my email list for a few years. I wrote five and seven-day sequences for different parts of my list. My email marketing software sent groups of subscribers a specific sequence depending on where they opted in. I spent hours writing and testing content in these sequences. After a few months, these sequences dated. If I changed my offer,...

A person holding a smart phone with social media on the screen

Hi Reader, Early last year, I hired a video coach. He’d a big viral account over on Insta. Thousands of followers and millions of views. I signed up for a three-month contract that cost $6k. Not cheap, but he helped me with a short-form content strategy for a few months. He taught me about great hooks, how to script the first 3 seconds of a video and retention curves. I followed his advice, and some of my videos went viral. The coach knew his stuff, and he delivered on his big promise but…...

A computer generated image of wavy lines

Hi Reader, I started meditating ten years ago. I meditate in the morning and evening for 10 minutes. I use a series of guided lessons from The Way. It’s a new app by American Zen Master Henry Shukman. HeadSpace and Waking Up are both good meditation apps, too. When I’ve more time, I meditate for 20 minutes twice a day without an app. For these sessions, I use a mantra. I picked up this mantra on a Transcendental Meditation course I took a few years ago. Yes, a real, in-person course… not one...