Be careful about attracting beginners


They often can’t afford what you sell or will try it once and move on.

Instead, create content for your ideal client instead, one can afford your offer and will do the work.

I wrote blog posts and articles for new authors and writers for a few years.

Two examples come to mind. I wrote a several thousand-word guide to using Scrivener for blogging, packed with pics, examples, and templates.

I also published a huge step-by-step breakdown about how to crowdsource great book covers over at 99designs.

Creating beginner content takes hours. I covered every step, including pics, supporting videos, explainers, and examples. It was kind of like writing a recipe but it took far longer. And I had to eat my own dinner, i.e. use Srivener to blog for a few months and spend money on getting a book cover from 99designs.

When I get this type of content right, it does well on search or social for a few months. I was OK with this measure of success for a few years. More search or social traffic meant more ad revenue.

I like it when DMs and comments roll in, too. They always fall into one of three camps.

Camp one says, “I followed your guide. It was great, thanks”. And I never hear from them again.

Camp two says something like, “Doesn’t work!” without providing context or information.

Camp three says something like, “I’ve got this great resource you could include in your guide” and proceeds to pitch their wares or product.

o what’s missing here?

You can’t make money from camp one, don’t pay attention to camp two, and camp three is trying to make money from your content.

I was fine with beginner content for a few years because I ran a content publishing business. I felt happy when a reader found a piece of my content helpful. And I got paid via ad revenue.

But I shifted my business model last year. Now, I work with clients. Traffic and ad revenue aren’t part of that model. So that means publishing far less beginner content.

Beginners can’t afford coaching or premium offers. Like running a high-end restaurant, you don’t want to attract people looking for fast food prices.

I’m better off creating premium content further up the value chain. It’ll get less traffic, but it should prove more profitable. That also means assuming a certain level of expertise for my ideal client or reader. If someone can’t follow along, they’re probably not a good fit.

On that…

I’m creating a paid newsletter offering custom Claude and ChatGPT prompts for creators. I’m assuming you’ve tried these tools and want to use them more. Reply ‘AI’ if you want first access.

If you like reading this, you’ll love my private, no-cost Telegram channel for pro creators. I share behind-the-scenes content about how I’m growing my content business. Join here

Letters From the Desk of Bryan Collins

Do you want to grow a profitable content business? If so, join 25,000 readers. I share daily insights about personal brand building, writing online and growing a profitable business. It's for creators, coaches and business owners.

Read more from Letters From the Desk of Bryan Collins
man wearing headphones while sitting on chair in front of MacBook

I’ve been spending more time posting content on Substack lately. The other day, I messaged a few creators new to the platform. Surprisingly, many of them are migrating from Medium to Substack. One ex-Medium writer told me she wanted a tutorial on using Substack. It’s a simple but intuitive platform that’s free of ads. If you’re not using Substack yet, here’s a 101 primer… followed by an explainer about my unconventional Substack strategy Start by creating a Substack profile. Upload a photo...

two hands touching each other in front of a blue background

Some writers and creators love using AI to write and create content. Others hate it. One newsletter reader even wrote in to tell me she hit the unsubscribe button because of my “blatant support of AI.” The last time I checked, OpenAI didn’t invite me into their seed round. That said, here’s my take: AI isn’t going anywhere, so I could pretend it doesn’t exist and get left behind or start using it for my business. I develop ideas for my content without AI and write what AI can’t generate....

A laptop computer sitting on top of a wooden table

I set up a live chat with some Substack subscribers the other day. I asked subscribers: What’s your number one question about writing online? The responses were variations of this conundrum: “How can I find the right audience?” Niche and audience selection kept me up at night for a few years, but I don’t worry so much about it anymore. Creating niche-specific content is a smart approach if you’re building a website. I ran a food and drinks website (not under my personal brand) for a few...